Tuesday, December 25, 2012

January 2, 2012 Discussion Topics

Brandywine Valley Civil War Round Table
Come to our next meeting
January 2, 2012
 
Speaker:
Traditional Roundtable Discussion
Topic:
See Topics Below
Time:
7:00 PM     
Place:
West Chester Borough Hall, Gay Street
 
Roundtable Discussion Topics
  1.  A turning point may be defined as: a decisive moment, or the deviation from a straight course. Which of the following was a turning point in the course of the American Civil War? 1) The death of Albert Sydney Johnson at the Battle of Shiloh? 2) Lee replacing Johnson at the Battle of Fair Oaks? 3) "Stonewall" Jackson dying of pneumonia following his wounding at Chancellorsville. EXPLAIN
  1. Clearly General McClellan seemed to have all the tools to be a succesful general for the Union. However it became clear he was no battlefield commander.  He lacked the ability to deal with the horrors of battle or take risks during combat.  If McClellan was less of an egotist would there have been a way he could have made a positive contribution to the war effort?
  1. Gettysburg today is seen as the major turning point in the war and also the start of the decline of Robert E. Lee's Army of Northern Virginia. However contemporaries just after the battle did not view Gettysburg in this way. Why is that?

  2. Discuss how the tactics specifically later in the war i.e. Petersburg contributed to the thoughts and methodology used on the Western Front in World War I

No comments:

Post a Comment